Given to Buffy by Jonathan and the "Class of 99" in the third season episode The Prom and seen again in the fourth season episode: The Freshman. Here is the award reproduced faithfully to that seen on screen using an umbrella with the correct number of panels on top (8) ,the correct "starry tinsel" and the name plaque with the words in the correct order (some have suggested that since Jonathan reads the plaque: "Buffy Summers--Class Protector" that this must be the order of the words on the plaque. The words and their correct order can be clearly seen at the end of the season four episode: The Freshman; "Class Protector--Buffy Summers"BuffyProps on Etsy